America's Next Top Model, Cycle 2
Original Channel UPN
Original Run January 13, 2004 –
March 23, 2004
Additional Information
No. of contestants 12
Winner Yoanna House
Catch-phrase "They are all gorgeous, but only one has what it takes"
Season chronology
Cycle 1
Cycle 3

America's Next Top Model Cycle 2, which premiered on January 13, 2004, was the second season of America's Next Top Model hosted by supermodel Tyra Banks, which aims to find the next top fashion model.

The judges for this cycle were: Tyra Banks, Janice Dickinson, Nigel Barker and Eric Nicholson.

The winner was 23 year old Yoanna House from Jacksonville, Florida.


Prizes this cycle include:

  • A modeling contract with IMG Models.
  • A fashion spread and cover in Jane Magazine.
  • A cosmetics campaign with Sephora.

The following prizes have been removed:

  • A modeling contract with Wilhelmina Models.
  • A photo spread in Marie Claire magazine.
  • A contract with Revlon cosmetics


(ages stated are at time of contest)

Contestant Age Hometown Outcome Post ANTM
Anna Bradfield 24 LaGrange, Georgia Eliminated in Episode 1 She has continued modeling, appeared on several lesser-known magazine covers, and been featured in a few Comcast TV commercials and Tyler Perry films. Has two sons.
Bethany Harrison 22 Houston, Texas Eliminated in Episode 2 Has done some test shots but did not further pursue a modeling career.
Heather Blumberg 18 Moreno Valley, California Eliminated in Episode 3
Jenascia Chakos 21 Burien, Washington Eliminated in Episode 4 Is the fashion director of Seattle's Dlist magazine, a professional stylist, and a self-proclaimed craft addict. She tweets and is an avid Instagram user. Appeared on Wheel of Fortune, where she won close to $50,000.
Xiomara Frans 25 Morganville, New Jersey Eliminated in Episode 5 Signed with Boss Models and appeared in New York Post´s Latino issue.
Catie Anderson 18 Willmar, Minnesota Eliminated in Episode 6 Signed with LA Models and New York Model Management and appeared in several runway shows and as a minor character on The Bold and the Beautiful. According to her Facebook, she now lives in New York City.
Sara Racey-Tabrizi* 23 Seattle, Washington Eliminated in Episode 7 Has left the modeling industry. Has her own company ATHLETEIST. Married to Pierre Batraville and has a son, Cyrus Christopher
Camille McDonald 25 Mamaroneck, New York Eliminated in Episode 8 Launched a line of lingerie called Lingerwear. She has shot for publications such as Glamour Magazine, WWD, and W Magazine. Camille is still very active on Twitter. Has a daugther; Kennedy.
April Wilkner 23 Miami, Florida Eliminated in Episode 10 Currently models in the US and in Asia and has modeled Vivienne Westwood, Alice and Olivia, Cynthia Rowley, and House of Deréon. She writes and produces her own segments on CBS and NBC, where she has also interviewed celebrities including Dr. Oz and Adriana Lima. She has also made acting appearances on USA Network.
Shandi Sullivan 21 Kansas City, Missouri Eliminated in Episode 11 Signed with Trump Model Management after the show, but has since left the industry, aside from some print work and test shots.
Mercedes Scelba-Shorte 22 Valencia, California Runner-up
Yoanna House 23 Jacksonville, Florida Winner
  • Sara celebrated her 23rd birthday in episode 7.

Episode summaries

The Girl Who Overslept

First aired January 13, 2004

The girls were picked up on a bus in New York where they met each other and started sizing up the competition. They are surprised to find themselves showing up on a U.S. Navy ship, were they meet Tyra and find out this is where they have their first runway show. Tyra commented, "They really didn't know what they were doing." The first photo shoot was a Garden of Eden-themed nude shoot for Fresh Look contact lenses, in which the women wore only sequins and body paint. One contestant, Anna, decided not to participate because, she said, it would insult her husband and child back home. Another, Jenascia overslept and arrived late for the shoot, despite other girls promises to wake the contestants when needed.

Model Eve
Anna Eve of the Sea
April Asian Eve
Bethany Eve of Winter
Camille Bird Of Paradise Eve
Catie Heavenly Eve
Heather Floral Eve
Jenascia Enchanting Archer Eve
Mercedes Egyptian Eve
Sara Medieval Eve
Shandi Fairy Tale Eve
Xiomara Eve of Temptation
Yoanna Eve of the Night

At panel, Camille, Mercedes, April, Sara, Heather and Shandi had pictures that stunned the judges, Yoanna's classic face was revered, and Bethany's bust was identified as a problem. Anna and Jenascia ended up in the bottom two. Though the judges were put off by Jenascia's tardiness, they ultimately chose to eliminate Anna, the plus-sized girl of the cycle, for refusing to do the photo shoot.

  • First call-out: Camille McDonald
  • Bottom two: Anna Bradfield & Jenascia Chakos
  • Eliminated: Anna Bradfield
  • Featured photographer: Nigel Barker
  • Special guests: Ed Libby, Jim De Yonker, Mike Randy, Ian Jones, Yohanea Cepeda

The Girl Who Floats Like a Butterfly and Stings Like a Bee

First aired January 20, 2004

The remaining eleven contestants received runway training from J. Alexander. At the subsequent walking challenge, Catie's gracefulness won her a trip to Carmen Marc Valvo's cocktail party, and she chose Mercedes and Camille to go with her. At the photo shoot, the girls were required to style themselves using Steve Madden 90210 shoes, before they picked their own best shot for the week. While Catie, Camille, Yoanna, and April did well, Bethany, Heather, and Jenascia somewhat struggled with selling the shoes.

Despite Shandi's lack of confidence and terrible runway walk, Bethany was cut, because the judges felt that she didn't know how to pose to flatter her large bust.

  • First call-out: Catie Anderson
  • Bottom two: Bethany Harrison & Shandi Sullivan
  • Eliminated: Bethany Harrison
  • Featured photographer: Ché Graham
  • Special guests: Martin Snow, Maggie Rizer, Carmen Marc Valvo

The Girl Who Can Cry At The Drop Of A Hat

First aired January 27, 2004

The girls got their makeovers, and some were more happy then others. Afterwards, Jay Manuel tested their make-up skills by giving the girls 15 minutes to apply make-up with one mirror, set of brushes, and palette between them. The winner, Yoanna, got a dinner with 3 friends (Sara, Xiomara, and April), while the rest of the girls shopped for, prepared, and served the dinner.

After the challenge, Shandi, who had complained about the heat of the room, collapsed due to exhaustion, causing the other girls to exert concern and aid in order to remedy the situation. She turned out fine, however, and vowed to make time for sleep and to eat as much as she could to prevent it from happening again. For the photoshoot, the contestants were suspended over a giant hole in the building wearing Laundry by Shelli Segal. Catie struggled because she feared falling to her death, but went through with 12 frames beautifully. In judging, Shandi wowed the judges with her immense improvement. Both April and Yoanna once again did well, and Sara finally showed she was more than just a pretty girl.

Xiomara and Heather were in the bottom two, both for their unsatisfactory photos, but Heather was eliminated for her lack of versatility and experience, and coming across too mall-girl.

  • First call-out: Shandi Sullivan
  • Bottom two: Heather Blumberg & Xiomara Frans
  • Eliminated: Heather Blumberg
  • Featured photographer: Richard Dean
  • Special guests: Edward Tricomi, Joel Warren, Karima Casteneda, Julie Redfern, Mike Sharits, Mike Randi, Eric Niemand, Halle Bowman

The Girl Who Needs Six Months Of Modeling School

First aired February 3, 2004

Camille's personality began to raise issues as she was singled out during a work out session where she and April were competing in a last man standing boxing challenge, which April ended up winning. The contestants' personal style was then critiqued by Tyra and Simon Doonan, who stated that Catie's look was whore-ish. Catie started crying and arguing with Simon, saying he called her a whore, which he didn't and it showed that the rest of the girls were sick of her acting. The contestants met Betsey Johnson and were challenged to dress in their personal style, but were only allowed to use everyone else’s clothes, not their own. Camille asked Xiomara to borrow some earrings for the show, but decided against using them, putting them on the counter which resulted in the earrings being broken. Camille said that she would get them fixed by her friend, who was a jewelry designer.

Betsey Johnson said Jenascia needed six months of modeling school in order to be right for her show, which is what the episode was named after. She told Catie that she still needed to find what style she had and who she was in order to do it correctly. She said Shandi's strength was that she was not a sexpot and that she shouldn't try to be that and chose her as the winner. The winner, Shandi, got dinner at JL with Cycle 1 winner, Adrianne Curry and picked Yoanna and Xiomara to join her.

The episode also focused on the fact that Mercedes had lupus and that she was scared because of her new medication making her hair fall out. She didn't want to tell the rest of the girls because she said she didn't need the sympathy. She vowed to make it to the top, despite what was going on with her health and to push through. For the photo shoot, the contestants portrayed celebrities. Xiomara was upset that she had to become a darker color to portray Grace Jones, and Mercedes used the pain of her lupus to portray Billie Holiday's pain.

Model Celebrity
April Catherine Zeta-Jones
Camille Diana Ross
Catie Marilyn Monroe
Jenascia Salma Hayek
Mercedes Billie Holiday
Sara Angelina Jolie
Shandi Nicole Kidman
Xiomara Grace Jones
Yoanna Audrey Hepburn

Mercedes used her lupus to her advantage, giving an emotional shot. Xiomara gave her strongest shot to date, and Yoanna proved she could be commercial, on a high fashion level. Camille's photo was highly praised, but her attitude came across as a major problem. In the end, it was Catie and Jenascia that were in the bottom 2, but Jenascia was eliminated because she couldn't compensate for her lack of height with stunning photographs or a personality that stood out in front of the judges.

  • First call-out: Mercedes Scelba-Shorte
  • Bottom two: Catie Anderson & Jenascia Chakos
  • Eliminated: Jenascia Chakos
  • Featured photographer: Andrew Eccles
  • Special guests: Simon Doonan, Adrianne Curry, Martin Snow, Danilo, Michael Carl, Betsey Johnson

The Girl Who Is A Visual Orgasm

First aired February 10, 2004

The girls underwent personality coaching. Shandi broke down after revealing her family treated her like the black sheep and a psychic did a reading for all the girls.

This week's reward challenge was a tricky interview with Janice Dickinson. Mercedes won the reward, a shopping spree, for answering the questions best and revealing her condition, lupus, which she had kept secret until then. She took Sara. Also as part of their reward, Mercedes', Sara's, and Tyra's moms all showed up.

The girls posed underwater for Quench Water. April gave the best photo of the cycle yet, but she came across too uptight in judging. Sara also did well, proving she could be both strong and soft in a photo. Shandi and Camille struggled, but not as much as Xiomara, who Nole said looked like a "walrus wearing chiffon". This eliminated her, despite Camille's bad attitude and dominatrix tendencies.

  • First call-out: Sara Racey-Tabrizi
  • Bottom two: Camille McDonald & Xiomara Frans
  • Eliminated: Xiomara Frans
  • Featured photographer: George Holz
  • Special guests: Sam Christensen, Suzannah Galland, Carolyn London, Nolé Marin

The Girl Whose Lip Puffed Up

First aired February 17, 2004

The photos for the week were simple black and white beauty shots that focused on their faces. Camille was late to the acting class because she went to see a doctor for her puffed up lip, which had swollen due to an allergic reaction. The contestants then participated in an acting challenge with Mark Collier. Camille decided to not follow the lines and instead, she rewrote parts of the script. Camille was then called clueless by the coach. The winner of the acting challenge was April.

The last stop was a Matrix themed commercial for Rollitos chips. April was hailed for her performance in the commercial and photo shoot, while Camille and Catie fell flat in both areas. Yoanna gave a shot that showed off her bone structure beautifully, and both Mercedes and Shandi showed off their beauty in their photos. Sara came across as pretty, but almost a bit too sexy in her photo. But, it was Camille and Catie in the bottom 2. Camille was criticized for her attitude, but Catie was sent home since judges felt that she was not emotionally prepared enough to handle the modelling industry.

  • First call-out: April Wilkner
  • Bottom two: Camille McDonald & Catie Anderson
  • Eliminated: Catie Anderson
  • Featured photographer: Bill Heuberger
  • Featured commercial director: James Gay
  • Special guests: Tasha Smith-Arqese, Mark Collier, De La Guarda, Eric Niemand, Kyle Hagler

The Girl Who Is Dripping With Hypocrisy

First aired February 24, 2004

The girls celebrated Sara's birthday, and Sara disclosed her passion for modeling, stating that she wanted it the most. The models then practiced dancing. April stepped it up for Tony Michaels and won the challenge. She took Shandi and Sara to a party with male guests.

Shandi acted flirty and fun with the male guests and was called on it by her boyfriend. They previously had an argument because he wanted to go to the movies with a friend of his who happened to be a girl named Lauren. Instead of a photo shoot, the contestants performed in Tyra's music video for "Shake Ya Body". During the shoot, April nearly pushed Yoanna off the runway, while walking on the wrong side. Shandi performed the best in her solo, Mercedes forgot the choreography and Yoanna messed up again and fell.

Yoanna was in the bottom two for her poor performance in the video, but a teary-eyed Tyra eliminated Sara, who the panel felt was too pin-up and sexy for the fashion world. The episode was followed by the premiere of the video.

  • First call-out: Shandi Sullivan
  • Bottom two: Sara Racey-Tabrizi & Yoanna House
  • Eliminated: Sara Racey-Tabrizi
  • Featured commercial director: Kennedy
  • Special guests: Rodney Jerkins, Tony Michaels

The Girl with the Signature Walk

First aired March 2, 2004

The remaining girls were taken to a restaurant where Tyra introduced their international destination for the cycle, Milan, Italy. The girls then went on go-sees where Shandi was described as the best high fashion model, Mercedes as being a bit commercial, April as photographing well but weak in other areas,and Yoanna having to work on her body. Camille won the challenge for her strong presence. At dinner in front of Tyra, Camille implied that Yoanna had an eating disorder which was not true.

The girls did a high fashion shoot for Solstice sunglasses featuring designs by Dior, Max Mara, Burberry, Gucci & Giorgio Armani. April had mixed reviews, Camille looked pigeon-toed and was the photographer's least favorite, Mercedes looked commercial, Yoanna hid her body well and Shandi took some of the photographer's best shots all year. She was also praised for her response to rather harsh designers (which turned out to be actors testing the models' attitudes) when asked why she should get booked. Shandi simply responded that if the designer would look at her photos they would possibly see something special there. Camille got the worst review, giving off an attitude that "she knew it all". While she was walking for the designers, they asked her why she walked the way she did, and Camille replied, "This is my signature walk, and it's the walk that's going to make me famous."

Mercedes was in the bottom two for looking commercial and for a lack of editorial potential, but it was Camille who was eliminated because of her attitude and getting very defensive all the time when critiqued.

  • First call-out: Shandi Sullivan
  • Bottom two: Camille McDonald & Mercedes Scelba-Shorte
  • Eliminated: Camille McDonald
  • Special guests: Kyle Hagler, David Brown, Elena Cimarosti, Carlo De Amici, Kesia Elwin, Liliana Rolando, Nolé Marin, Michael Giannini
  • Featured photographer: Massimo Costoli

The Girl Who Is Afraid Of Snakes

First aired March 9, 2004

This was the cycle's recap episode. It was so named because April was afraid when it was implied that they might have to handle such creatures in a photoshoot.

The Girl Who Cheated

First aired March 16, 2004

Male models were invited to come over to the house and had fun with the girls, where Shandi, who was overwhelmed by loneliness of being apart from her boyfriend, ended up having sex with another male model. Lambasted by a sense of guilt, she called her boyfriend, Eric, the next day and told him what happened. Eric got mad and yelled at her before he finally hung up. The next day, Shandi called him back and he wished her good luck in the next photo shoot.

This week, the girls learned how to compliment their body with their attire. Then, they were put into the test where they shopped at a flea market and found an outfit that was high fashion and complemented their body the best. Shandi was chosen as the winner and picked Yoanna to join in her reward.

For this week's photo shoot, the girls teamed up to do a sensual, romantic nude shoot. At panel, Mercedes impressed the judges at the judging challenge with her ability to make a piece of cloth look like a high fashion shirt. April was criticized for trying to take control of the photo shoot and Mercedes was criticized for looking too commercial. In the end, April was sent home for being too technical.

  • First call-out: Yoanna House
  • Bottom two: April Wilkner & Mercedes Scelba-Shorte
  • Eliminated: April Wilkner
  • Featured photographers: Almicare Incalza, Alex Martinengo
  • Special guests: Jean Luc, Nolé Marin, Loris Rocchi, Stephen Fairchild

The Girl Who Is America's Next Top Model

First aired March 23, 2004

For the final photo, the final three had a beauty shot for which they were dressed in the opposite of their normal styles. At judging, Mercedes was hailed for finally looking like a high-fashion model. Yoanna's photo received praise, but the judges wondered if her body was right for the modeling industry. Shandi gave a pretty photo, but wasn't up to par with the other two. This eliminated her, despite giving some of the best photos in the competition.

  • First call-out: Mercedes Scelba-Shorte
  • Bottom two: Shandi Sullivan & Yoanna House
  • Eliminated: Shandi Sullivan
  • Featured photographer: Massimo Costoli

After the shoot, the remaining two met up with Dean and Dan of Dsquared for whom they walked in a fashion show. During the show, Yoanna broke her high heels and had to use Mercedes' heel, but was able to successfully complete the show.

At panel, the judges were immensely impressed by Mercedes and they felt that she stole the runway show. Tyra recognized the uniqueness of Yoanna's face, and believed that Yoanna knew the modeling industry better than Mercedes. After a long and hard deliberation, both finalists were called in and Yoanna was declared the second winner of America's Next Top Model.

  • Final two: Mercedes Scelba-Shorte & Yoanna House
  • America's Next Top Model: Yoanna House
  • Special guests: Nolé Marin, Gian Luca Guaitoli, Dean Caten, Dan Caten

Contestant gallery

Anna Bradfield

Eliminated in episode 1

Bethany Harrison

Eliminated in episode 2

Heather Blumberg

Eliminated in episode 3

Jenascia Chakos

Eliminated in episode 4

Xiomara Frans

Eliminated in episode 5

Catie Anderson

Eliminated in episode 6

Sara Racey-Tabrizi

Eliminated in episode 7

Camille McDonald

Eliminated in episode 8

April Wilkner

Eliminated in episode 10

Shandi Sullivan

Eliminated in episode 11

Mercedes Shelba-Shorte


Yoanna House


0212.11 yoanna-house.jpg

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.